Season 5" >
Guests" >
Ranks" >
CAST & PRODUCERS" >
Season 4" >
Season 5" >
Fanfic" >
Hall Of Fame" >
The Lost Island Awards" >
Creative Forum" >
Jokes" >
Polls" >
LOST ISLAND :: Discuss Season 5 Episode 5 "This Place Is Death"
Discuss Season 5 Episode 5 "This Place Is Death" here!!!
_________________
Thu Feb 12, 2009 9:34 pm
cheryl Jack & League of X
Joined: 02 Jan 2007 Posts: 2514
Location: Loveland, Colorado, USA
DAMN them for killing Red (charlotte) off...........................................................
_________________ LIVE SIMPLY. LOVE GENEROUSLY. CARE DEEPLY. SPEAK KINDLY. LEAVE THE REST TO GOD
Thu Feb 12, 2009 9:51 pm
Sawbucks LOST ISLAND & League Of X
Joined: 29 Aug 2006 Posts: 7219
Location: Hawick, Scotland
Ajrgbdfsbbnjwjhiuhwayu!!!!! Now that I've got that formality out of the way, I'd just like to say that this was a very solid episode, with revelations (Some of them admittedly predictable) coming from all directions. Of course, there was one slight negative point about the episode (And by slight I mean mind-numbingly enraging), so until such a time that I've come to accept that, comments from me on this episode will be few and far between.
Let the grieving process commence.
_________________ #5 Member of the 'League of X' elite board.
Thu Feb 12, 2009 10:15 pm
LOSTjunkie Ben & League of X
Joined: 11 Mar 2007 Posts: 2302
Location: Middle of Frickin' Nowhere
moment of truth: i hardly had any reaction to Red being killed off..sorry, just dont really care about her, only her back story which i have faith that we will get without her alive soo...
anyways, amazinggg episode!! probs best so far this season!
Sawyer was amazing as usual. the scene where him & Jin meet up again was great! Sawyer finally has a friend with him again.
Locke & Christain were great as well.
Immediately recognized Rousseau's music box.
Smokey!!!!!!!
Ben is effin incredible.
Mrs. Hawkins=Daniel Faraday's mom =]
Desmond!! yay!! though does this mean Penny is in danger??
Geronimo Jackson shoutout!!!!
& soooo much more
_________________ I love Adam Lambert!!
Roswell is love.
Fri Feb 13, 2009 3:20 am
X-Men_God Site Admin & Owner
Joined: 23 Aug 2006 Posts: 6974
Location: LOST ISLAND
Okay this is my favourite episode of the Season so far!!!
It was perfect!!!
Firstly there was a death and a very moving one at that! I'm very sad to see Charlotte go! Though I expect we'll be seeing Young/Child-Charlotte soon!!!
Secondly, SMOKEY IS BACK!!! Got love ol' Smokey and it was cool to see that Smokey was responsible for Montand losing his arm!!!
I'm loved the Rousseau origin story though I hope we see Danielle losing Alex to Ben and the Others.
Christian and Locke was just genius!!! I'm desperate to know what's going on with Christian though! Is he Jacob? Is he Smokey? Is he ALIVE?!?!
Also, I wonder if Locke will learn that Jack is his son!!!
Jin was great in this episode and his reunion with Sawyer was great! It was sad seeing him tell Locke to tell Sun he had died though!
It was also cool how they managed to drop a Geronimo Jackson shout-out too!
Mrs Hawkins IS Faraday's mother, no surprise there but great all the same!
And I'm looking forward to seeing Ben, Eloise, Jack, Kate, Sun and Desmond begin planning the trip back to the island! I'm glad Desmond is involved in the return!
I wonder if Aaron and Frank have to go back too?
I loved Ben's tantrum in the van! He's great!!!!
Locke has now left the island! Looking forward to seeing what he said to the O6 and what caused his death!!!
A perfect episode in my opinion!!!
10/10!!!
_________________
Mon Feb 16, 2009 3:03 pm
Sawbucks LOST ISLAND & League Of X
Joined: 29 Aug 2006 Posts: 7219
Location: Hawick, Scotland
OK, I'm starting to come to terms with the latest fatality, though I'm still less than pleased with it. Though now I've started wondering who else's name will be added to the list of deceased between now and the end of the series. I don't doubt that at least one person will be bumped off at next season, and there's still the possibility that the Reaper comes a-callin' later on this year...I've been reasonably lucky when it comes to main character deaths, because (With the exception of one) none of my favourite characters have been killed off (Though I've still realy liked all the ones that have anyway). The chances of this continuing through to the show's end are becoming slimmer with each death, especially since I'm starting to love all the remaining characters more and more each episode...Who will be next?
Anyway, I thought it was great to see Rousseau's arrival on the island and whatnot. I hope we haven't seen the last of her, but I wouldn't be surprised if this was the final instalment in the Danielle Rousseau story...
Smokey's return was awesome, I wonder if it was the monster him/her/itself that made Robert & co. "change", or if it was something else down that hole? Also, did anyone else think of Austin Powers when Montand got dragged down the hole and then starting shouting up about him being hurt?
Ben's hissy fit in the van was great, it was such an uncharacteristically impatient and angry Ben. Just shows how much pressure and strain he's under right now, especially since he had Sayid, Kate and Aaron within his grasp and they all escaped his clutches. (On that note, Sayid's parting words to Jack were classic Jarrah. One of the many reasons he's my favourite character on this show).
One thing I did find unusual was how at the end of episode 2, Ms Hawking said "God help us all" in reference to what would happen if Ben couldn't reunite all of the Oceanic Six, but in this episode she seemed fairly calm and happy enough to continue without everyone...
_________________ #5 Member of the 'League of X' elite board.
Tue Feb 17, 2009 1:21 pm
Dharma_Dork Dr Arzt
Joined: 22 Oct 2006 Posts: 175
Location: Birmingham, UK
What a fantastic episode. Yet again I'm forced to re-grow my fingernails, only to loose them the following sunday! I hardly knew charlotte and she made me cry almost as much as Libby & Ana lucia. We finally saw the temple. The smoke apparently lives inside, and I reckon the secret room in Ben's house is connected to the temple. Hence the attack on the mercenaries by smokey. Also the reason as to why Ben sent his people to the temple. The Dharma Initiative must have known about the monster, and its connection to the temple, thus the reason the barracks are, where they are. This bloody beast still has me kerfuddled.
So are we to believe that Charlotte is a Hostile and not Dharma, she knew about the well, which existed before the Orchid. I'm guessing the well wasn't built to collect water. The well IMHO ties into the general look of the whole ancient-nes of the temple and Ben's secret room. Perhaps the Dharma stations were all built on pre existing wonders of the island.
So Locke has re-aligned the wheel, does this mean that the island has moved once more? I also cant wait to see how Locke ends up in the middle of nowhere with a broken leg!
I also noted how the wheel looks just like a dharma wheel, coincidence??
The best quote from the episode:
Locke: Can you help me up?
Christian: No..........
Funniest moment:
Ben's tantrum in the car.
I love ben he has the greatest one liners. 'I flushed them down the toilet' still cracks me up!
So the next episode according to good old sky plus is called 316, I wonder if this is the name of a flight. If so i wonder who they fly with, it'd be good if they flew with the Indian airline. but they'll probably rely on oceanic, it's free. I also wonder if they literally fly to or crash near the island. hey i'm jumping the gun they might not even be flying.
10/10 for this place is death.
OOH also Heroes for the UK continues on Monday @ 9.00 but hey lets face it we've already seen it right? which reminds me Ben, i've purchased the sword of Hiro Nakamura I truly am a lost soul......
_________________ Secret0Window
Tue Feb 17, 2009 8:42 pm
LOSTjunkie Ben & League of X
Joined: 11 Mar 2007 Posts: 2302
Location: Middle of Frickin' Nowhere
Sawbucks wrote:
I've been reasonably lucky when it comes to main character deaths, because (With the exception of one) none of my favourite characters have been killed off
can't pretend that i've been that lucky
Quote:
(On that note, Sayid's parting words to Jack were classic Jarrah. One of the many reasons he's my favourite character on this show).
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum